Open Access

Helium-oxygen reduces the production of carbon dioxide during weaning from mechanical ventilation

Respiratory Research201011:117

https://doi.org/10.1186/1465-9921-11-117

Received: 15 November 2009

Accepted: 26 August 2010

Published: 26 August 2010

Abstract

Background

Prolonged weaning from mechanical ventilation has a major impact on ICU bed occupancy and patient outcome, and has significant cost implications.

There is evidence in patients around the period of extubation that helium-oxygen leads to a reduction in the work of breathing. Therefore breathing helium-oxygen during weaning may be a useful adjunct to facilitate weaning. We hypothesised that breathing helium-oxygen would reduce carbon dioxide production during the weaning phase of mechanical ventilation.

Materials/patients and methods

We performed a prospective randomised controlled single blinded cross-over trial on 19 adult intensive care patients without significant airways disease who fulfilled criteria for weaning with CPAP. Patients were randomised to helium-oxygen and air-oxygen delivered during a 2 hour period of CPAP ventilation. Carbon dioxide production (VCO2) was measured using a near patient main stream infrared carbon dioxide sensor and fixed orifice pneumotachograph.

Results

Compared to air-oxygen, helium-oxygen significantly decreased VCO2 production at the end of the 2 hour period of CPAP ventilation; there was a mean difference in CO2 production of 48.9 ml/min (95% CI 18.7-79.2 p = 0.003) between the groups. There were no significant differences in other respiratory and haemodynamic parameters.

Conclusion

This study shows that breathing a helium-oxygen mixture during weaning reduces carbon dioxide production. This physiological study supports the need for a clinical trial of helium-oxygen mixture during the weaning phase of mechanical ventilation with duration of weaning as the primary outcome.

Trial registration

ISRCTN56470948

Introduction

Weaning from mechanical ventilation is estimated to account for up to 40% of the total duration of ventilatory support [1]. The process of weaning patients therefore has a major impact on ICU bed occupancy with significant cost implication [2]. Strategies to facilitate weaning have a major potential to reduce use of healthcare resources [3, 4].

Helium is an inert gas and prolonged administration to animals has demonstrated no adverse effects [5]. Helium has a lower density and higher viscosity compared with oxygen and nitrogen. Breathing helium leads to a decreased resistance in gas flow, a change from turbulent to laminar flow patterns [6] and a reduction in the work of breathing. However a change from turbulent to laminar flow patterns is unnecessary for the reduction in the work of breathing which can occur under fully turbulent flow [7].

Helium-oxygen has been used in clinical situations where upper or lower airways obstruction or disease leads to an increased resistance to flow. Although there are many case reports of successful use of helium-oxygen in these conditions, to date no studies have conclusively demonstrated improved outcomes in these patient groups [8].

There are limited data regarding the use of helium-oxygen during weaning. Use of a helium-oxygen mixture during weaning with CPAP has been successfully used to improve respiratory distress and improve PaO2 after cardiovascular surgery in a small study in infants [9]. In addition, in ventilated patients with airflow obstruction, breathing helium-oxygen during a T-piece breathing trial just prior to extubation resulted in a reduction in airway resistance and consequently a decrease in work of breathing [10].

The aim of this physiological study was to determine whether breathing a helium-oxygen mixture as compared with an air-oxygen mixture during the weaning phase of mechanical ventilation would reduce carbon dioxide production in patients without significant airways obstruction.

Materials and methods

We conducted a prospective single centre, randomised, single blinded, controlled, cross-over study in our 18 bed mixed medical-surgical ICU. Approval for the study was obtained from Research Ethics Committee and the Medicines and Health Regulatory Agency (MHRA). Eligible patients were ready for weaning to CPAP and had to meet the following inclusion criteria; the underlying cause of respiratory failure was improving, pressure support ventilation of less than 10 cmH2O, no continuous intravenous sedation or inotropes, FiO2 less than or equal to 0.4 and requiring less than 10 cmH2O positive end expiratory pressure. Written informed consent from the patient or assent from their next of kin was obtained.

Respiratory parameters were measured using a near patient main stream infrared carbon dioxide sensor and fixed orifice pneumotachograph connected to a respiratory profile monitor (CO2SMO Plus Respiratory Monitor, Novametrix Medical systems, Wallingford, CT, USA) and analysed using computer software (Analysis plus). The capnograph is barometric pressure compensated with an accuracy of +/- 2 mmHg (for 0 - 40 mmHg) and +/- 5% of the reading (for 41 - 70 mmHg). The pneumotachograph is a disposable device using differential pressure with an overall accuracy of +/-2%. This device was calibrated for the specific fraction of inspired helium and oxygen on an individual patient basis according to the manufacturer's instructions. On initialisation the device performs a zero calibration. The accuracy of the infrared carbon dioxide sensor is further verified by using a calibration device for carbon dioxide. Furthermore a previous study showed the monitoring device remained stable and accurate over a 48 hour period of continuous monitoring[11]. Alveolar minute ventilation, respiratory rate and CO2 production were continuously recorded by the CO2SMO plus monitor. Representative base line carbon dioxide production in a 70 kg male is 200 ml/min. An average of a 5 minute period of these parameters was recorded before the start of CPAP as a baseline and at 1 and 2 hours during each CPAP period with the study gases. Systolic and diastolic blood pressure and heart rate were recorded directly by means of an indwelling arterial catheter and electrocardiogram (ECG) attached to a bedside monitor. Arterial partial pressure of carbon dioxide and oxygen were obtained over a 2-hour period from arterial blood gas samples.

Patients were randomly assigned to initially breath either Heliox or air-oxygen mixtures. Patients were blinded to the gas mixture they received. Data was collected directly to a laptop computer and the researcher and study statistician who analysed the data were blinded to the gas mixtures. Following baseline measurements, patients received 2 hours of CPAP ventilation (PEEP setting remained unchanged and pressure support set to zero) with helium-oxygen or air-oxygen via an eVent ventilator (eVent Medical Inc. 81 Columbia Suite 101, Aliso Viejo, CA 92656). This ventilator was calibrated for the helium oxygen mixture on an individual patient basis according to the manufacturer's instructions. Patients were returned to their pre study ventilator settings for 2 hours, before being given the alternative gas mixture for 2 hours.

The level of CPAP support and FiO2 were unchanged for individual patients throughout the trial period. The study CPAP trial was defined as unsuccessful and discontinued if the patients developed two or more of the following criteria: respiratory rate > 40 breaths/min or rapid shallow breathing index (RSBI) > 105; SpO2 <90% or SpO2 decrease to >8% from the patients baseline value; HR > 140 beats/min or HR changes by >20% from the patients baseline; systolic blood pressure >200 mmHg or < 80 mmHg or systolic blood pressure changes by >20% of baseline; deterioration in conscious level, defined as a fall in GCS of >2, or if the patient became agitated/sweating/anxious.

The data were tested for normality and a paired t-test was used to test the treatment effect on within-subject differences. A priori the 2-hour time point was used as a summary measure of treatment effect. The data were expressed as means, standard deviations (SD) and 95% confidence intervals (CI). A p-value of < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Results

Twenty-three patients were recruited into the study. A total of 19 completed the study protocol and their baseline characteristics are displayed in Table 1. Patients were treated with mechanical ventilation for a median 9 days (inter-quartile range, IQR, 6-12 days). The primary underlying condition was neurological in 8 patients, medical in 4 patients, polytrauma in 6 patients with 1 surgical patient. One patient was recruited with an infective exacerbation of COPD.
Table 1

Patient characteristics

Patient number

Age

Primary reason condition

Secondary reason condition

APACHE II

Status at unit discharge

Length of unit stay (rounded)

Length mechanical ventilation till inclusion

1

21

Status epilepticus or uncontrolled seizures

 

17

Alive

11

9

2

77

Pulmonary haemorrhage not defined

Thoracic or thoraco-abdominal aortic aneurysm

22

Alive

21

12

3

84

Inhalation pneumonitis (smoke or gases)

 

19

Alive

11

12

4

44

Pneumonia, no organism isolated

Depression

14

Alive

9

5

5

84

Haemorrhage or haematoma from pelvis, long bones or joints

Fractured ribs

23

Alive

30

12

6

65

Intracerebral haemorrhage

Secondary hydrocephalus

20

Alive

5

2

7

30

Traumatic rupture or laceration of liver

Hypovolaemic shock

16

Alive

17

13

8

68

Lung collapse or atelectasis

Lung abscess

16

Alive

23

6

9

46

Primary (diffuse) brain injury

Lumbar spine fracture or ligamentous injury

25

Alive

27

26

10

47

Primary (diffuse) brain injury

Amputation of limb

15

Alive

10

6

11

72

Primary (diffuse) brain injury

Traumatic subarachnoid haemorrhage

19

Alive

9

7

12

76

Abdominal aortic aneurysm, ruptured

Acute renal failure due to haemodynamic causes

18

Dead

12

7

13

45

Primary (diffuse) brain injury

Pneumonitis due to food and vomit

10

Alive

13

10

14

18

Traumatic myocardial perforation

Anoxic or ischaemic coma or encephalopathy

12

Alive

22

17

15

36

Tracheal trauma or perforation

Traumatic pneumothorax

19

Alive

20

12

16

28

Traumatic subdural haemorrhage

Focal brain injury

9

Alive

10

8

17

58

Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease with acute exacerbation, unspecified

 

15

Alive

3

1

18

79

Traumatic subdural haemorrhage

 

28

Alive

6

4

19

67

Pneumonia, no organism isolated

Pleural effusion

24

Alive

12

9

Mean

53.3

  

17.3

 

13.9

9.2

SD

21.7

  

5.0

 

7.6

5.7

Median

      

9

IQR

      

6-12

Four patients did not have evaluable data and were not included in the analysis. One patient became anxious when commenced on CPAP and withdrew consent (helium-oxygen), in 2 patients the respiratory rates exceeded the protocol within 15 minutes of commencing CPAP and were returned to their pre-study ventilatory support (1 helium-oxygen, 1 air-oxygen) and 1 patient was randomised but developed epileptic seizures just prior to starting CPAP and was withdrawn. Fifteen of the patients were studied on an FiO2 of 0.3 or less, three patients were on an FiO2 0.35 and one patient on an FiO2 of 0.4. Nine patients received helium-oxygen mixture first compared to ten receiving air-oxygen first.

Compared to air-oxygen, helium-oxygen significantly decreased VCO2 production at the end of the 2 hour period of CPAP ventilation (Figure 1) There was a mean difference in CO2 production of 48.9 ml/min (95% CI 18.7-79.2 p = 0.003) between the groups. There were no significant differences between baseline and 2 hours CPAP with air-oxygen and helium-oxygen in all other respiratory and heamodynamic parameters measured (Table 2).
Table 2

Respiratory and haemodynamic parameters during the study period

 

Baseline

Helium/oxygen after 2 hours CPAP

Baseline

Air/oxygen after 2 hours CPAP

Statistical significance

RR, breaths/min

24 +/- 7

25 +/- 5

26 +/- 6

25 +/- 6

NS

PaCO2, kPa

5.2 +/- 1.0

5.2 +/- 1.0

5.4 +/- 1.1

5.4 +/- 1.2

NS

PaO2, kPa

11.3 +/- 2.1

11.2 +/- 1.8

12.7 +/- 2.3

11.7 +/- 2.4

NS

Minute volume

10.2 +/- 2.8

10.8 +/- 2.5

10.6 +/- 2.3

10.2 +/- 2.4

NS

HR, beats/min

89 +/- 14

89 +/- 13

88 +/- 14

91 +/- 14

NS

SBP, mmHg

128 +/- 27

126 +/- 23

126 +/- 23

130 +/- 27

NS

DBP, mmHg

63 +/- 8

62 +/- 10

63 +/- 11

65 +/- 12

NS

Temperature

37 +/- 1

37 +/- 1

37+/- 1.5

37 +/- 1

NS

Definitions of abbreviations; RR = respiratory rate; HR = heart rate; SBP = systolic blood pressure; DBP = diastolic blood pressure; NS = non significant.

Values are means +/- standard deviation

Figure 1

Carbon dioxide production over time in hours for heliox and air.

Discussion

Our study showed a significant reduction in CO2 production in patients without significant airways disease. This supports the need for a definitive clinical study of Heliox in weaning from mechanical ventilation to be undertaken. We were surprised by the 19% reduction in CO2 production seen while breathing helium oxygen although this is in keeping with a 21% reduction in work of breathing shown by Diehl et al in their study [10]

Weaning from mechanical ventilation has a major impact on ICU bed occupancy and patient outcome, and has significant cost implications. Strategies to facilitate weaning have a major potential to improve patient outcome and reduce the use of healthcare resources. We demonstrate in this physiological study that patients weaning from mechanical ventilation show a significant reduction in carbon dioxide production when breathing a helium-oxygen mixture. We found that all other respiratory and cardiovascular parameters measured showed no significant changes from baseline values.

In our study we used CO2 production as a surrogate for the work of breathing. Studies have confirmed that inspiratory muscular work of breathing is proportional to the exhaled volume of CO2 per minute after allowing a period of time for stabilisation of CO2 [1214]. Our findings are consistent with previous studies using helium-oxygen in intubated patients with COPD during controlled ventilation and on pressure support ventilation during the weaning phase of ventilation [15, 16]. These studies have shown a reduction in total, resistive and elastic work of breathing with helium-oxygen mixtures. In spontaneously breathing patients with COPD during a T-piece trial there was a reduction in work of breathing from 1.4 to 1.1 J/L in 13 patients with COPD and a reduction in intrinsic positive end expiratory pressure PEEPi [10]. Change in flow from turbulent to transitional or laminar by the use of the less dense helium is thought to be a major reason for improvement in gas flow. However, a study by Papamoschou, demonstrated that helium-oxygen does not need to be laminar to improve flow and benefits exist even if flow remains turbulent [7]. In a study in 18 patients without COPD studied immediately post-extubation, helium-oxygen given for 15 minutes reduced inspiratory effort as measured by transdiaphragmatic pressure changes. A significant subjective improvement in respiratory comfort was also observed. This benefit reversed when patients were returned to air-oxygen [17]. However as patients were already weaned to the point of extubation, no conclusion can be drawn as to whether helium-oxygen improved the weaning phase. A further small study of helium use in infants post-cardiac surgery, during weaning, showed a reduction in CO2 production and an increase in PaO2 reflecting a reduction in work of breathing [9]. Our current study extends these previous data to a group of general adult intensive care unit patients without significant airways disease during the weaning phase of mechanical ventilation. While this physiological study has demonstrated a beneficial but transient effect on CO2 production with the short-term use of a helium mixture, future studies designed to investigate the effect on duration of weaning would require longer term use of helium mixture.

It is worth noting that helium can interfere with the function of ventilators and in particular, flow measurement devices. It is therefore important that clinicians are aware of the effects helium can have on the equipment they use, and equipment must be compatible with, and calibrated for, use with helium [18].

This study has several limitations. The aim of this physiological study was to measure CO2 production in patients without documented obstructive airways disease. It is not possible to exclude that a proportion of the patients had unrecognised small airways obstruction. The study is limited by the small number of patients and one patient had a documented history of COPD. Importantly when this patient is removed from the analysis the beneficial effect of helium-oxygen is still significant. In addition, we used CO2 production as a surrogate for work of breathing. Carbon Dioxide production is one of the indirect calorimetric methods of measuring metabolic rate. Factors other than work of breathing that increase metabolic rate will likely increase CO2 production. No changes to the physical workload of our patients were made during the study period. Furthermore there was no difference in other measured respiratory and haemodynamic parameters or temperature as shown in Table 2. This indirectly indicates that the change in CO2 production is likely to indirectly reflect work of breathing. Measurements of trans-oesophageal pressures or pressure-volume loop would have been useful to more directly assess work of breathing but unfortunately these were not available.

In conclusion, our study demonstrated a significant reduction in CO2 production, as a surrogate measure of work of breathing, in adult patients during the weaning phase of ventilation breathing a helium-oxygen mixture. This provides support for a clinical study powered for duration of weaning as the primary outcome to be undertaken.

Abbreviations

CO2

carbon dioxide

COPD: 

chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

CPAP: 

continuous positives airway pressure

DBP: 

diastolic blood pressure

FiO2

fraction inspired oxygen

HR: 

heart rate

RR: 

respiratory rate

NS: 

non significant

PEEPi: 

positive end expiratory pressure intrinsic

SBP: 

systolic blood pressure

RSBI: 

rapid shallow breathing index

Declarations

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank all the staff from the ICU who participated in this study. Dr Fiona Warburton Statistician, Joint R&D Office Barts & the London NHS Trust.

Authors’ Affiliations

(1)
Intensive Care Unit, Royal London Hospital, Whitechapel
(2)
Respiratory Medicine Research Programme, Centre for Infection and Immunity, The Queen's University of Belfast
(3)
Intensive Care Unit, Prince of Wales Hospital

References

  1. Esteban A, Alia I, Ibanez J, Benito S, Tobin MJ: Modes of mechanical ventilation and weaning. A national survey of Spanish hospitals. The Spanish Lung Failure Collaborative Group. Chest 1994, 106:1188–1193.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  2. MacIntyre NR, Cook DJ, Ely EW Jr, et al.: Evidence-based guidelines for weaning and discontinuing ventilatory support: a collective task force facilitated by the American College of Chest Physicians; the American Association for Respiratory Care; and the American College of Critical Care Medicine. Chest 2001, 120:375S-395S.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  3. Esteban A, Frutos F, Tobin MJ, et al.: A comparison of four methods of weaning patients from mechanical ventilation. Spanish Lung Failure Collaborative Group. N Engl J Med 1995, 332:345–350.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. MacIntyre NR: Evidence-based ventilator weaning and discontinuation. Respir Care 2004, 49:830–836.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  5. Barach AL: Use of Helium as a New Therapeutic Gas. 1934, 462–464.Google Scholar
  6. Otis AB, Bembower WC: Effect of gas density on resistance to respiratory gas flow in man. J Appl Physiol 1949, 2:300–306.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  7. Papamoschou D: Theoretical validation of the respiratory benefits of helium-oxygen mixtures. Respir Physiol 1995, 99:183–190.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Colebourn CL, Barber V, Young JD: Use of helium-oxygen mixture in adult patients presenting with exacerbations of asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a systematic review. Anaesthesia 2007, 62:34–42.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  9. Tatsuno K, Imai Y, Konno S: Therapeutic use of helium-oxygen mixture in continuous positive airway pressure for early weaning from mechanical ventilation after cardiovascular surgery in infants. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1976, 72:119–122.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  10. Diehl JL, Mercat A, Guerot E, et al.: Helium/oxygen mixture reduces the work of breathing at the end of the weaning process in patients with severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Crit Care Med 2003, 31:1415–1420.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  11. Rockmann F: Evaluation of a new combined CO2 and respiratory monitoring system. Clinical intensive care ed 2004, 123–129.Google Scholar
  12. Arnold JH, Thompson JE, Arnold LW: Single breath CO2 analysis: description and validation of a method. Crit Care Med 1996, 24:96–102.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Sutton PJ, Perkins CL, Giles SP, McAuley DF, Gao F: Randomised controlled cross-over comparison of continuous positive airway pressure through the Hamilton Galileo ventilator with a Drager CF 800 device. Anaesthesia 2005, 60:72–76.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  14. Taskar V, John J, Larsson A, Wetterberg T, Jonson B: Dynamics of carbon dioxide elimination following ventilator resetting. Chest 1995, 108:196–202.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  15. Gainnier M, Arnal JM, Gerbeaux P, Donati S, Papazian L, Sainty JM: Helium-oxygen reduces work of breathing in mechanically ventilated patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Intensive Care Med 2003, 29:1666–1670.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  16. Tassaux D, Gainnier M, Battisti A, Jolliet P: Helium-oxygen decreases inspiratory effort and work of breathing during pressure support in intubated patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Intensive Care Med 2005, 31:1501–1507.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  17. Jaber S, Carlucci A, Boussarsar M, et al.: Helium-oxygen in the postextubation period decreases inspiratory effort. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2001, 164:633–637.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  18. Tassaux D, Jolliet P, Thouret JM, Roeseler J, Dorne R, Chevrolet JC: Calibration of seven ICU ventilators for mechanical ventilation with helium-oxygen mixtures. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1999, 160:22–32.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar

Copyright

© The Author(s) 2010

This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.