Skip to main content

Table 2 Characteristics of the changes

From: Care programs and their components for patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis: a systematic review

Name of the program

What is the focus of change?

Which format is used?

What are the elements of the program?

Which main types of outcomes were assessed?

Overview of the care program or component thereof without implementation in routine clinical care yet (n = 7)

 Hospital2Home [31]

Palliative care

Nurse-led case conference

Multidisciplinary team-based care

Lead of the conference: trained palliative care specialist nurse

Involvement patient/caregiver in decision-making

Situated in community setting

Individual care plan and follow-up of action points

Primary outcomes: Palliative Care Outcome Scale

Other outcomes:

Patient-reported outcomes

Feasibility

Patient experiences

 Aerodigestive multidisciplinary team [39]

Assessment co-morbidity

Multidisciplinary team meeting

Multidisciplinary team-based care

Medical care

Clinical outcomes

Feasibility

 PRISIM [46]

Support- Coping

Group-based sessions

Psychoeducation

6-weeks program with two-hour group sessions

Patient-reported outcomes

Patient experiences

 Nurse-led support group [40]

Support- Advocacy group

Support group

Patient advocacy/support group (two-hour meetings once a month)

Lead of the group: nurse

Patient-reported outcome

 IPF online [37, 45]

Use of eHealth in care

eHealth platform

eHealth personal platform including information, PROMs, medication use, individual results of lung function tests and medication coach

eConsult possibility

Home-based spirometry function

Feasibility and safety

Patient-reported outcomes

Patient experiences

 MBSR [36]

Support- Coping

Mindfulness-based stress reduction program (group-based sessions)

Standardised mindfulness training (eight weekly group sessions and further training at home)

Use of techniques such as the body scan, sitting mediation and light yoga

Sessions provided by a MBSR instructor

Primary outcome: safety

Patient-reported outcomes

Feasibility

 PPEPP [32]

Support- Coping

Group-based sessions

Psychoeducation (three group sessions)

Lead of the sessions: psychologist

Contributions to the sessions by pulmonologist, a nurse specialized in ILD, an oxygen supplier, a social worker and physiotherapists

Patient-reported outcomes

Patient satisfaction

Overview of the care programs or components thereof implemented in routine care (n = 6)

 SCDAT

Collaborative MDT meeting [33, 34]

Palliative care and advanced care planning

Tool for the assessment of needs

Multidisciplinary team meeting

Tool used by clinicians in outpatient setting to assess patients’ needs

Follow-up multidisciplinary team-based care (palliative care consultant, palliative care nurse, psychologist, ILD consultant, ILD nurse, pharmacist and MDT coordinator)

Process measures

Stakeholders’ feedback

 NPP [41]

Pharmacological management program

Follow-up visits

Nurse-led support of pharmacological needs

Clinical outcomes (description)

 IPF care [43]

Pharmacological management program

Nurse-led telephone program

UK program: program led by nurses specialized in ILD, telephone contact

Austria program: program led by nurses specialized in ILD, telephone contact and home visit

Clinical outcomes

Patient satisfaction

Feasibility

 An educational initiative: performance improvement study [35]

Overall organisation of the care program

Follow-up team-based care

Performance improvement initiative: An educational initiative to improve team-based care in which metrics (quality indicators) are used to assess, measure and adapt the delivered care

Performance indicators (process measures)

Stakeholders’ experiences

 Use of care coordinator [42]

Overall organisation of the care program

Follow-up care with coordinator

Case coordination (similar to specialist IPF nurse): assessment and administration, patient education, discussing transplantation, drug reimbursements, discussing drugs, oxygen therapy, discussing tests and results

Patient-reported outcomes

Patient satisfaction

Process measures

Economic analysis

 MDC care model [38, 44]

Palliative care and advanced care planning

Multidisciplinary collaborative care model

Collaborative multidisciplinary team-based care

Involvement patient/caregiver in decision-making

Individual care plan and follow-up of action points

Close link with community

Healthcare use

Preferred place of death

Caregivers’ experiences