Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of randomized controlled trials included

From: Efficacy and safety of antagonists for chemoattractant receptor-homologous molecule expressed on Th2 cells in adult patients with asthma: a meta-analysis and systematic review

Source

Study Design

Participants characteristics

Population

Intervention (Drug, Dose, Frequency)

Control

Concomitant treatments

Duration

Follow-up

Outcomes*

Barnes 2012 [11]

Multi-center, parallel-group, RCT

Steroid-free, moderate persistent asthma

132

OC000459, 200 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA

4 weeks

10 weeks

①⑤⑥⑦⑨⑪⑫⑯⑲

Pettipher 2014 [12]

Multi-center, parallel-group, RCT

Mild-to-moderate persistent steroid-free asthma

482

OC000459, 25 mg, Once daily

Placebo

SABA

12 weeks

20–22 weeks

①⑤⑪⑯⑰⑱

OC000459, 200 mg, Once daily

OC000459, 100 mg, Twice daily

Singh 2013 [13]

Multi-center, two-period, cross-over, RCT

Steroid-naïve mild allergic asthma

21

OC000459, 200 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA

16 days

35–41 days

①③⑫⑭⑮⑯

Hall (trial 1) 2015 [14]

Multi-center, parallel-group, RCT

Symptomatic, mild-to-moderate, steroid-naïve asthma

317

BI 671800, 50 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA

6 weeks

10 weeks

③⑯⑰⑱⑲

BI 671800, 200 mg, Twice daily

BI 671800, 400 mg, Twice daily

Hall (trial 2) 2015 [14]

Symptomatic, mild-to-moderate asthmatic patients on ICS

176

BI 671800, 400 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA, ICS

10–12 weeks

③⑯⑰⑱⑲

Bateman 2017 [16]

Multi-center, parallel-group, RCT

Allergic asthma inadequately controlled with low-dose ICS

901

Fevipiprant, 1 mg/3 mg/ 10 mg or 2 mg, Once daily or twice daily

placebo

SABA or ICS

12 weeks

22–24 weeks and 2 days

⑪⑭⑯⑰⑱⑲

Fevipiprant, 30 mg/50 mg/ 75 mg or 25 mg, Once daily or twice daily

Fevipiprant, 150 mg/300 mg or 75 mg/ 150 mg, Once daily or twice daily

Fevipiprant, 450 mg, Once daily

Busse 2013 [17]

Multi-center, parallel-group, RCT

Inadequately controlled, moderate-to-severe asthma

396

AMG 853, 5 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA, ICS

12 weeks

18 weeks

①②③④⑤⑥⑧⑨⑩⑪⑫⑭⑯⑰⑱⑲

AMG 853, 25 mg, Twice daily

AMG 853, 100 mg, Twice daily

AMG 853, 200 mg, Twice daily

Erpenbeck 2016 [18]

Multi-center, parallel-group, RCT

mild-to-moderate persistent allergic asthma

170

Fevipiprant, 500 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA

4 weeks

8 weeks

⑧⑩⑯⑰

Fowler 2017 [19]

Single-center, parallel-group, RCT

Well controlled mild asthma

84

BI 1021958, 5/20/60/200 mg or 40/150/400 mg, Twice daily or once daily

Placebo

SABA

15 days

15 days

⑯⑰⑱⑲

Gonem 2016 [20]

Single-center, parallel-group, RCT

Persistent, moderate-to-severe eosinophilic asthma

61

Fevipiprant, 225 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA, ICS, LABA, or oral prednisone

12 weeks

20 weeks

①②⑧⑨⑫⑬⑭⑯⑰

Kuna (trial 1) 2016 [21]

Multi-center, parallel-group, RCT

Stable asthma withdrawn from ICS

113

AZD1981, 1000 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA

4 weeks

8 weeks

①②⑤⑦⑥⑩⑫⑬⑭⑯⑰⑱⑲

Kuna (trial 2) 2016 [21]

Multi-center, parallel-group, RCT

Uncontrolled moderate-to-severe asthma despite moderate-to-high dose of ICS

368

AZD1981, 50 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA, ICS

4 weeks

8 weeks

①⑦⑯⑰⑱⑲

AZD1981, 400 mg, Twice daily

AZD1981, 1000 mg, Twice daily

Wenzel 2014 [22]

Multi-center, parallel-group, RCT

Steroid-free, mild atopic asthma

184

ARRY-502, 200 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA

4 weeks

6 weeks

①⑧⑨⑪⑯⑲

Bateman 2018 [23]

Multi-center, parallel-group, RCT

Persistent allergic asthma

1144

AZD1981, 80/200 mg, once daily,

or 10/40/100 mg, twice daily

Placebo

ICS, LABA, SABA

12 weeks

15 weeks

①⑧⑪⑯⑰⑱

Diamant 2014 [24]

Multi-center, two-period, cross-over, RCT

Stable, allergic asthma

14

Setipiprant, 1000 mg, Twice daily

Placebo

SABA

5 days

37 days

⑬⑭⑮

Miller 2017 [25]

Multi-center, three-period, cross-over, RCT

Mild-to-moderate symptomatic asthma

108

BI 671800, 400 mg, Once daily (a.m)

Placebo

SABA, ICS

12 weeks

16–18 weeks

③⑧⑯⑰⑱⑲

  1. *Outcomes include: ① change of pre-bronchodilator FEV1, ② change of post-bronchodilator FEV1, ③ change of pre-bronchodilator FEV1% predicted, ④ change of post-bronchodilator FEV1% predicted, ⑤ change of morning PEF, ⑥ change of evening PEF, ⑦ change of FVC, ⑧ change of ACQ scores, ⑨ change of AQLQ scores, ⑩ change of SABA use, ⑪ incidence of asthma exacerbation, ⑫ change of sputum eosinophils, ⑬ change of blood eosinophils, ⑭ change of FeNO, ⑮ change of methacholine PC20, ⑯ incidence of adverse events, ⑰ incidence of severe adverse events, ⑱ incidence of treatment related adverse events, ⑲ incidence of adverse events leading to treatment withdrawal
  2. ACQ asthma control questionnaire, AQLQ asthma quality of life questionnaire, FeNO fractional exhaled nitric oxide, FEV1 forced expiratory volume in one second, FVC forced vital capacity, Methacholine PC20 the provocation concentration of methacholine causing a 20% fall in FEV1, NM not mentioned, PEF peak expiratory flow, RCT randomized controlled trial, SABA short-acting beta-agonists