Decreased respiratory system compliance on the sixth day of mechanical ventilation is a predictor of death in patients with established acute lung injury
© Seeley et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2011
Received: 4 January 2011
Accepted: 22 April 2011
Published: 22 April 2011
Multiple studies have identified single variables or composite scores that help risk stratify patients at the time of acute lung injury (ALI) diagnosis. However, few studies have addressed the important question of how changes in pulmonary physiologic variables might predict mortality in patients during the subacute or chronic phases of ALI. We studied pulmonary physiologic variables, including respiratory system compliance, P/F ratio and oxygenation index, in a cohort of patients with ALI who survived more than 6 days of mechanical ventilation to see if changes in these variables were predictive of death and whether they are informative about the pathophysiology of subacute ALI.
Ninety-three patients with ALI who were mechanically ventilated for more than 6 days were enrolled in this prospective cohort study. Patients were enrolled at two medical centers in the US, a county hospital and a large academic center. Bivariate analyses were used to identify pulmonary physiologic predictors of death during the first 6 days of mechanical ventilation. Predictors on day 1, day 6 and the changes between day 1 and day 6 were compared in a multivariate logistic regression model.
The overall mortality was 35%. In multivariate analysis, the PaO2/FiO2 (OR 2.09, p < 0.04) and respiratory system compliance (OR 3.61, p < 0.01) were predictive of death on the 6th day of acute lung injury. In addition, a decrease in respiratory system compliance between days 1 and days 6 (OR 2.14, p < 0.01) was independently associated with mortality.
A low respiratory system compliance on day 6 or a decrease in the respiratory system compliance between the 1st and 6th day of mechanical ventilation were associated with increased mortality in multivariate analysis of this cohort of patients with ALI. We suggest that decreased respiratory system compliance may identify a subset of patients who have persistent pulmonary edema, atelectasis or the fibroproliferative sequelae of ALI and thus are less likely to survive their hospitalization.
Acute lung injury (ALI) is a major cause of morbidity and mortality in ICUs throughout the world [1–3]. Despite improvements in ventilation strategies and supportive care, the mortality from ALI remains between 30-60%. Due to this high mortality, rescue therapies such as extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO), inhaled nitric oxide, prone positioning and high frequency oscillatory ventilation are often considered for patients who are perceived to be at the highest risk of death.
Identifying patients at the highest risk of death has been a barrier to effectively testing and implementing these therapies. Physiologic measures that predict increased mortality when measured at the time of admission include an elevated dead space fraction, a low oxygenation index and an increased extravascular lung water [3–5]. However, important decisions regarding therapeutic interventions and changes in goals of care are often made later in the course of illness. Few studies have focused on pulmonary physiologic variables that might be associated with death during this crucial time period. Thus, we performed a study of pulmonary physiologic variables in a cohort of patients who survived more than 6 days of mechanical ventilation. The objectives of this study were two-fold. First, using multivariate analysis, we hoped to identify independent predictors of death that might help identify patients at risk for poor outcomes and thus best suited for experimental therapies for ALI. Second, through a physiologic investigation of pulmonary mechanics over the first 6 days of mechanical ventilation, we sought to develop a deeper understanding of the pulmonary pathophysiology that might lead to death during ALI.
Material and methods
Patients who met the North American-European consensus conference definition of ALI  in both medical and surgical intensive care units were identified prospectively as a part of ongoing clinical trials of ALI between July 1st 2002 and June 30th 2003. All enrolled patients were 18 years or older and there were no exclusion criteria for enrollment. Select data on 149 consecutive patients were collected prospectively, and additional data were then extracted from the medical record retrospectively. In order to identify predictors of mortality in established ALI, 93 out of 149 patients who survived more than 6 days of mechanical ventilation for ALI were included in this study. The 56 (149 minus 93) patients excluded from the original cohort were either extubated (27 patients) or died (29 patients) before the 6th day of mechanical ventilation. The association between several pulmonary physiologic variables measured at the time of study enrollment (for all 149 patients) and the outcome of death has been published . This study was conducted at the University of California Moffitt-Long Hospital, a tertiary university referral center, and at San Francisco General Hospital, a large, inner-city hospital and Level 1 trauma center. Data collection was approved by the institutional review board of the University of California, San Francisco. For data collected retrospectively, the requirement for written informed consent was waived. Ventilator management was at the discretion of the critical care team. However, both hospitals had implemented the lung-protective ventilation protocol of the ARDS Net trial on either a formal or an informal basis and >90% of patients were noted to be on either volume controlled or pressured regulated volume controlled ventilatory modes.
The plans for data collection and analyses were defined prospectively, before review of the medical records began. Data were recorded at a daily reference time between 0600 and 1000. A reference quasi-static respiratory system compliance (Crs) reflected the average daily Crs in a subset of subjects . The quasistatic respiratory compliance was calculated by dividing the difference between the tidal volume and the volume compressed in the ventilator circuit by the difference between the plateau pressure and the positive end-expiratory pressure or [(TV - Volume left in circuit)/(Ppl - PEEP)].
Clinical data were abstracted from the medical record for up to 6 days or until the time of death or extubation, whichever occurred first. These data included the etiology of ALI, coexisting medical illnesses, the use of glucocorticoids or other causes of immunosuppression, fluid intake/output and balance, vital signs, and chest radiographic findings. The clinical disorder associated with ALI was considered primary if the cause was pneumonia, aspiration, direct lung trauma, or inhalational injury. All other causes were considered secondary.
Laboratory data collected were electrolytes, blood urea nitrogen, creatinine, white blood cell count, and hematocrit. Mechanical ventilation variables included arterial blood gases, peak inspiratory pressure, plateau pressure (Pplat), positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP), mean airway pressure (mean Paw), tidal volume (VT) in both mL and mL/kg predicted body weight (PBW), respiratory frequency (f), and minute ventilation ( ). Calculated variables included the lung injury score (LIS) , APACHE II , SAPS II , PaO2/FiO2, and respiratory system compliance. The oxygenation index (OI) was calculated as [mean airway pressure x FiO2 x 100] ÷ PaO2 . For patients with trauma-induced ALI, the Injury Severity Score  was determined.
The primary outcome variable of this study was death prior to hospital discharge. Multiple physiologic variables on each day of mechanical ventilation were compared using bivariate analyses. These bivariate analyses were considered exploratory and undertaken to identify variables for the multivariate analysis, thus, p values were calculated without correction for multiple comparisons. Continuous normally distributed variables were compared using a Student's t-test, and categorical variables were compared using the Fisher's exact test. Select predictor variables that were statistically significant or that were of a priori clinical interest were entered into a backward stepwise, multivariate logistic regression model. Separate multivariate logistic regression models were developed for predictor variables measured at day 1, day 6, and the change in value between day 1 and 6. Stata 9.0 (StataCorp, College Station, Texas) computer software was used for statistical analysis. All interval data in tables and text are presented as mean with standard deviation in parentheses. Data presented in graphs are mean with error bars indicating the standard error of the mean (SEM). The odds ratios for death are calculated per standard deviation increase or decrease in each variable to allow for equal comparisons between different variables. The goodness-of-fit of the logistic-regression model was assessed with the Hosmer-Lemeshow test, all p values for the H-L test were >0.05, indicating that the model was well calibrated. Results were considered to be statistically significant at two-tailed p < 0.05.
Baseline characteristics of 93 patients who survived more than 6 days of mechanical ventilation for ALI
All Patients (n = 93)
Survivors (n = 60)
Non-Survivors (n = 33)
P value (S vs. NS)
Age (Mean (SD))
APACHE II score
OI (cmH20/mm Hg)
Respiratory system compliance (ml/cm H20)
Tidal Volume (ml)
Tidal Volume (ml/kg PBW)
Duration of Mechanical Ventilation
Gender (% female)
Primary cause of ARDs
Bivariate Analysis - Admission
There were several notable differences between survivors and non-survivors at the time of ALI diagnosis (Table 1). Non-survivors were older and had higher SAPS II and APACHE II scores. In addition, survivors were more likely to have trauma as the cause of their ALI (12% vs. 0%, p = 0.048) and had higher body weight corrected tidal volumes (7.8 ± 1.9 vs. 6.7 ± 2.5, p = 0.02). A higher percentage of non-survivors were on vasopressors at the time of ALI diagnosis (64% vs. 35%, p = 0.01), which may be due to a higher prevalence of septic shock in non-survivors. There was no difference in the percent of patients with a primary cause for ALI between survivors and non-survivors (primary cause in 43% vs. 36%, p = 0.65).
Bivariate analysis of respiratory variables for 93 patients with acute lung injury who were ventilated for more than 6 days
Crs (ml/cm H 2 0)
Pplat (cm H 2 0)
OI (cmH 2 0/mm Hg)
P/F ratio (cm H 2 0)
PEEP (cm H 2 0)
Paw (cm H 2 0)
Bivariate Analysis - Changes Over Time
Multivariate adjusted odds ratio of death for selected variables on day 1, day 6 and the change in each variable between day 1 and day 6
Δ Day 1 ➔ Day 6
Predictors of death in established ALI are important and clinically relevant for two reasons. First, previous studies have reported an average duration of mechanical ventilation in ALI between 5 and 16 days, suggesting that a large proportion of patients with ALI are alive and mechanically ventilated 6 days after the diagnosis of ALI [13–15]. Second, important management decisions to escalate or limit the intensity of care are often made during this time interval. In this prospective cohort study of 93 patients with ALI who survived 6 or more days of mechanical ventilation, we found that a low or decreasing respiratory system compliance on the 6th day of mechanical ventilation was associated with an increased risk of death. This finding is novel because few other studies have identified pulmonary predictors of mortality in ALI patients ventilated with lung-protective ventilation during this stage of disease. In addition, if prospectively validated, these findings may help identify patients who are failing traditional therapy and who might benefit from novel rescue therapies.
Although the cumulative risk of complications associated with mechanical ventilation, including ventilator-associated pneumonia and sepsis, increases with each ventilator day, we were surprised to find that the mortality of patients who were ventilated for 6 or more days was similar to patients enrolled in our previous study  which included patients who died or were extubated during the first 6 days of ALI (35% vs. 42%, p = 0.42). Other studies, including the Kings County Lung Injury Project and the ARDSNet trial of steroids for persistent ARDS, reported surprisingly low mortality rates in patients requiring prolonged ventilation for ALI as well [13, 14, 16, 17]. The low mortality in this study may be because the sickest patients who present with severe shock, catastrophic injury, or refractory hypoxemia die during the first 6 days of ALI and thus were not included in this analysis.
Previous studies of pulmonary predictors of mortality in ALI have focused on early predictors of mortality [18, 4, 19, 20] or on physiologic changes between the onset of ALI and the third day of mechanical ventilation [21, 19, 20] in patients ventilated with traditional tidal volumes. In this study, the OI was the only variable predictive of death on the first day of lung injury in bivariate analysis. The OI was an independent predictor of mortality in the complete cohort of patients , and as previously published, is a clinically practical, early predictor of death in both adult  and pediatric  ALI populations. Contrary to previous reports , measures of pulmonary mechanics, including respiratory system compliance and Pplat, were not predictive of death on the first day of mechanical ventilation. This difference from prior studies may be partially attributable to the use of lung-protective ventilation, which could attenuate alveolar stretch during mechanical ventilation.
On the 2nd and 3rd day of ALI, none of the physiologic variables measured in this study were associated with death. In contrast, previous studies found one or more predictors of death on days 2 and 3 of ALI. Cooke at al  examined predictors of mortality in a cohort of 1,113 patients with ALI and found that the change in PaO2/FiO2 ratio between the day of diagnosis and day 3 of hospitalization was predictive of death. Similarly, Estenssoro et al  examined a cohort of 217 patients in Argentina and found that the PaO2/FiO2 ratio was predictive of death on the third day of mechanical ventilation. Lastly, Gajic et al  retrospectively analyzed multiple physiologic variables on day 3 of mechanical ventilation in a large observational trial and then validated it in two independently collected data sets. Gajic et al found that PaO2/FiO2 ratio, Pplat, mean Paw, PEEP and OI on the third day as well as the change in OI and PEEP between days 1 and 3 were predictive of a composite end point of death or ventilator dependence 15 days after intubation.
Three important distinctions may account for the differences between our study, which did not identify pulmonary predictors of death on days 2 or 3 of ALI and the 3 studies reported above. First, patients in our study were managed with a lung-protective ventilation strategy, which may standardize plateau airway pressure and oxygenation. Second, the cohort size may have limited our ability to find statistical differences between survivors and non-survivors on days 2 and 3 of mechanical ventilation. Lastly, our study included only patients who survived >6 days of ALI, thus eliminating patients who died early due to refractory hypoxemia, catastrophic trauma or fulminant septic shock. Although the subgroup of patients who die of hypoxemia is small (approximately 15%), this difference could have driven the statistical significance of the PaO2/FiO2 ratio on the third day of ALI in prior studies [23, 24].
The major finding of this study was that a low or decreasing respiratory system compliance on the 6th day of mechanical ventilation is an independent predictor of mortality in this cohort of patients. Respiratory system compliance may decrease in non-survivors due to a combination several factors, including volume overload, atelectasis and early pulmonary fibroproliferation. Patients with refractory shock may have required more fluid boluses to maintain adequate blood pressures and this may have lead to worsening pulmonary and chest wall edema. Although our data set had greater than 15% missing data for volume administration, there was no statistical difference in daily or cumulative fluid balance between survivors and non-survivors. A higher level of lung collapse and atelectasis may also contribute to decreased compliance in non-survivors. The amount of recruitable lung identified by CT scanning has been shown by others to be associated with mortality during ALI . In the context of our data, lower respiratory system compliance may be indicative of more atelectasis and thus relative over-distention of healthier lung units despite the use of lung-protective ventilation. Lastly, respiratory system compliance may decrease in non-survivors due to the fibroproliferative phase of ALI which can occur as early as the 6th day of mechanical ventilation in autopsy studies . Biochemical studies have identified procollagen peptide I and III, which are precursors of fibrotic collagen, in BAL fluid at the time of ALI diagnosis and the amount of peptide in this specimens correlates with mortality . Future studies utilizing esophageal manometry to accurately estimate the contribution of chest wall or abdominal pressure to total respiratory system compliance, with more complete records of volume administration and weight changes as well as pathologic studies of patient who die during the later phases of ALI could provide a mechanistic explanation for these physiologic findings.
This study has several limitations. First, the small study size may have limited our ability to detect statistical differences in physiologic variables on days 2 and 3 of mechanical ventilation. Second, this study was conducted at an academic and county hospital; thus these findings might not be generalizable to community hospital populations. Third, post-hoc selection of patients can lead to selection bias; however, we believe that our strict criterion (>6 days of mechanical ventilation) for entry into this study was the best way to answer our study question. Fourth, extensive information on transfusion of blood products, a known risk factor for ALI, were not collected. Lastly, due to a small study size we were unable to divide this population into a derivation and validation cohort. Future replication of these findings in a separate cohort of patients with ALI would substantiate our results.
In conclusion, we studied the association of changes in pulmonary physiologic variables with death in a cohort of ALI patients who were mechanically ventilated for more than 6 days. Using multivariate analysis, we found that both the absolute value of respiratory system compliance on day 6 and the decrease in respiratory system compliance between days 1 and 6 of mechanical ventilation for ALI are associated with increased mortality. We hypothesize that decreased respiratory system compliance may be indicative of persistent pulmonary or chest wall edema, atelectasis of inflamed lung or evidence of the early fibroproliferative phase of ALI. If these results can be replicated prospectively in a larger set of ALI patients, then a low or decreasing respiratory system compliance, interpreted in the context of other known predictors of mortality in ICU patients, may help identify patients at the highest risk of death from ALI during the subacute phase of illness.
Funded by NHLBI RO1 HL51856, R37HL51856.
- Hudson LD, Milberg JA, Anardi D, Maunder RJ: Clinical risks for development of the acute respiratory distress syndrome. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1995,151(2 Pt 1):293–301.PubMed
- Doyle RL, Szaflarski N, Modin GW, Wiener-Kronish JP, Matthay MA: Identification of patients with acute lung injury. Predictors of mortality. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1995,152(6 Pt 1):1818–1824.PubMed
- Nuckton TJ, Alonso JA, Kallet RH, Daniel BM, Pittet JF, Eisner MD, Matthay MA: Pulmonary dead-space fraction as a risk factor for death in the acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med 2002,346(17):1281–1286.PubMedView Article
- Seeley E, McAuley DF, Eisner M, Miletin M, Matthay MA, Kallet RH: Predictors of mortality in acute lung injury during the era of lung protective ventilation. Thorax 2008,63(11):994–998.PubMedView Article
- Craig TR, Duffy MJ, Shyamsundar M, McDowell C, McLaughlin B, Elborn JS, McAuley DF: Extravascular lung water indexed to predicted body weight is a novel predictor of intensive care unit mortality in patients with acute lung injury. Crit Care Med 38(1):114–120.
- Bernard GR, Artigas A, Brigham KL, Carlet J, Falke K, Hudson L, Lamy M, LeGall JR, Morris A, Spragg R: Report of the American-European Consensus conference on acute respiratory distress syndrome: definitions, mechanisms, relevant outcomes, and clinical trial coordination. Consensus Committee. J Crit Care 1994,9(1):72–81.PubMedView Article
- Kallet RHMD, Milliten M, Matthay MA: Reference respiratory system compliance (Crs) measurements as a reflection of average Crs in acute lung injury (ALI) and acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2004, 169:A780.
- Murray JF, Matthay MA, Luce JM, Flick MR: An expanded definition of the adult respiratory distress syndrome. Am Rev Respir Dis 1988,138(3):720–723.PubMed
- Knaus WA, Draper EA, Wagner DP, Zimmerman JE: APACHE II: a severity of disease classification system. Crit Care Med 1985,13(10):818–829.PubMedView Article
- Le Gall JR, Lemeshow S, Saulnier F: A new Simplified Acute Physiology Score (SAPS II) based on a European/North American multicenter study. JAMA 1993,270(24):2957–2963.PubMedView Article
- Bone RC, Maunder R, Slotman G, Silverman H, Hyers TM, Kerstein MD, Ursprung JJ: An early test of survival in patients with the adult respiratory distress syndrome. The PaO2/FIo2 ratio and its differential response to conventional therapy. Prostaglandin E1 Study Group. Chest 1989,96(4):849–851.PubMedView Article
- Linn S: The injury severity score--importance and uses. Ann Epidemiol 1995,5(6):440–446.PubMedView Article
- Ventilation with lower tidal volumes as compared with traditional tidal volumes for acute lung injury and the acute respiratory distress syndrome. The Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome NetworkN Engl J Med 2000,342(18):1301–1308.
- Rubenfeld GD, Caldwell E, Peabody E, Weaver J, Martin DP, Neff M, Stern EJ, Hudson LD: Incidence and outcomes of acute lung injury. N Engl J Med 2005,353(16):1685–1693.PubMedView Article
- Esteban A, Anzueto A, Frutos F, Alia I, Brochard L, Stewart TE, Benito S, Epstein SK, Apezteguia C, Nightingale P, et al.: Characteristics and outcomes in adult patients receiving mechanical ventilation: a 28-day international study. JAMA 2002,287(3):345–355.PubMedView Article
- Steinberg KP, Hudson LD, Goodman RB, Hough CL, Lanken PN, Hyzy R, Thompson BT, Ancukiewicz M: Efficacy and safety of corticosteroids for persistent acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med 2006,354(16):1671–1684.PubMedView Article
- Hough CLSK, Caldwell E, et al.: Duration of mechanical ventialtion is not associated with hospital mortality in patients with acute lung injury. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2006,3(3):A831.
- Gajic O, Afessa B, Thompson BT, Frutos-Vivar F, Malinchoc M, Rubenfeld GD, Esteban A, Anzueto A, Hubmayr RD: Prediction of death and prolonged mechanical ventilation in acute lung injury. Crit Care 2007,11(3):R53.PubMedView Article
- Cooke CR, Kahn JM, Caldwell E, Okamoto VN, Heckbert SR, Hudson LD, Rubenfeld GD: Predictors of hospital mortality in a population-based cohort of patients with acute lung injury. Crit Care Med 2008,36(5):1412–1420.PubMedView Article
- Estenssoro E, Dubin A, Laffaire E, Canales H, Saenz G, Moseinco M, Pozo M, Gomez A, Baredes N, Jannello G, et al.: Incidence, clinical course, and outcome in 217 patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome. Crit Care Med 2002,30(11):2450–2456.PubMedView Article
- Luecke T, Muench E, Roth H, Friess U, Paul T, Kleinhuber K, Quintel M: Predictors of mortality in ARDS patients referred to a tertiary care centre: a pilot study. Eur J Anaesthesiol 2006,23(5):403–410.PubMedView Article
- Trachsel D, McCrindle BW, Nakagawa S, Bohn D: Oxygenation index predicts outcome in children with acute hypoxemic respiratory failure. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2005,172(2):206–211.PubMedView Article
- Montgomery AB, Stager MA, Carrico CJ, Hudson LD: Causes of mortality in patients with the adult respiratory distress syndrome. Am Rev Respir Dis 1985,132(3):485–489.PubMed
- Ferring M, Vincent JL: Is outcome from ARDS related to the severity of respiratory failure? Eur Respir J 1997,10(6):1297–1300.PubMedView Article
- Gattinoni L, Caironi P, Cressoni M, Chiumello D, Ranieri VM, Quintel M, Russo S, Patroniti N, Cornejo R, Bugedo G: Lung recruitment in patients with the acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med 2006,354(17):1775–1786.PubMedView Article
- Fukuda Y, Ishizaki M, Masuda Y, Kimura G, Kawanami O, Masugi Y: The role of intraalveolar fibrosis in the process of pulmonary structural remodeling in patients with diffuse alveolar damage. Am J Pathol 1987,126(1):171–182.PubMed
- Meduri GU, Tolley EA, Chinn A, Stentz F, Postlethwaite A: Procollagen types I and III aminoterminal propeptide levels during acute respiratory distress syndrome and in response to methylprednisolone treatment. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1998,158(5 Pt 1):1432–1441.PubMed
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.